The Rules for Rulers

Chia sẻ
Nhúng
  • Xuất bản 24 Th10, 2016
  • Part 2: vnclip.net/video/ig_qpNfXHIU/video.html
    Grey discusses this video on Cortex: vnclip.net/video/ILvD7zVN2jo/video.html
    Adapted from 'The Dictators Handbook', go read it: amzn.to/2fgBWps
    Che Greyvara T-Shirt: cgpgrey.com/chegrey
    Special Thanks:
    Bruce Bueno de Mesquita & Alastair Smith
    &
    Mark Govea, Thomas J Miller Jr MD, dedla , Robert Kunz, John Buchan, Ripta Pasay, Saki Comandao, Andres Villacres, Christian Cooper, Michael Little, PervertedThomas , Nevin Spoljaric, سليمان العقل, Tony DiLascio, Richard Jenkins, Chris Chapin, Faust Fairbrook, Jason Lewandowski, Michael Mrozek, Jordan LeDoux, Chris Woodall, rictic , Ian , Tod Kurt, Phil Gardner, Chang Wang, Kozo Ota, Jordan Melville, Martin , Steven Grimm, Joe Pantry, Colin Millions, Muhammad Shifaz, Chris Harshman, Jose Reyes, Guillermo , Ron Bowes, Tómas Árni Jónasson, Mikko , Derek Bonner, Derek Jackson, Orbit_Junkie , Timothy Basanov, David Michaels, Mark Elders, Donal Botkin, Veronica Peshterianu, Paul Tomblin, Travis Wichert, chrysilis , Ryan E Manning, Erik Parasiuk, Rhys Parry, Maarten van der Blij, Kevin Anderson, Ryan Nielsen, Esteban Santana Santana, Dag Viggo Lokøen, Tristan Watts-Willis, John Rogers, Edward Adams, Leon , ken mcfarlane, Brandon Callender, Timothy Moran, Peter Lomax, Emil , Tijmen van Dien, ShiroiYami , Alex Schuldberg, Ryan Constantin, Bear , Jacob Ostling, Solon Carter, Rescla , Hystiklopp , Andrew Proue, Tor Henrik Lehne, David Palomares, Cas Eliëns, Freddi Hørlyck, Ernesto Jimenez, Osric Lord-Williams, Maxime Zielony, Lachlan Holmes , John Lee, Ian N Riopel, AUFFRAY Clement, John Bevan, Robert Grünke (trainfart)
    Music by: www.davidreesmusic.com

NHẬN XÉT • 22 743

  • Shamino Warhen
    Shamino Warhen 23 giờ trước

    Elizabeth II's cabinet was often paid with kind words, if ever paid at all. Will Durant notes in The Story of Civilization: The Age of Reform, Elizabeth handed the key positions to people who could simply not be bought. The simple idea of paying treasure = gains loyalty is reductive and absurdist- it makes me lament Italian history, where this exact same sort of thinking lead to perpetual backstabbing for 1200 years.

  • bhargav r bhat
    bhargav r bhat Ngày trước

    If your citizens have better access to education and helthcare they would revolt against dictatorship
    CCP *Implements nation-wide censorship *
    *insert surprise Pikachu face*

  • Unlucky Lucy
    Unlucky Lucy Ngày trước

    Your definition of democracy is very anti-democratic.

  • Joe Follo
    Joe Follo Ngày trước

    This video is so dramatic even though it’s just stick figures

  • Giuseppe Massari
    Giuseppe Massari Ngày trước

    Well this was depressive.



    If incredibly informative

  • william evans
    william evans 2 ngày trước

    Your videos are Awesome.

  • Phil Borgen's Social Acc
    Phil Borgen's Social Acc 2 ngày trước +2

    The best solution i see is the one most likely for the future.
    Artificial Intelligence.
    It puts the question of loyalty in a meaningless position.
    All that's needed then is a leader strong enough not to get mad with power.
    Maybe an AI as well?...

    • Phil Borgen's Social Acc
      Phil Borgen's Social Acc 6 giờ trước

      Nothing other than that it would be changed to do a flawless job if it didn't. If only people were that easy...

    • t. intelectuel
      t. intelectuel 6 giờ trước

      what's stopping people from overthrowing artificial intelligence?

  • Phil Borgen's Social Acc
    Phil Borgen's Social Acc 2 ngày trước

    If people were actually fighting for a better world rather than individual selfish gain this wouldn't have to be such a problem...

  • Calvin K
    Calvin K 3 ngày trước

    This is what Trump and the republicans are trying to do.. People.... they will spend on their yes men to keep the power but will not waste money giving it to the people. REMEMBER THAT!!!!!!!

  • maya assata
    maya assata 3 ngày trước

    best argument for communism online!

  • Cukřík z Bohnic
    Cukřík z Bohnic 3 ngày trước +1

    Isn't it all about the people
    -said nobody ever

  • DeathΩMessenger
    DeathΩMessenger 3 ngày trước

    That explains why Doctor Doom's entire army is made up by robots, no?
    Because they aren't stupid, self-centered meatbags who need to be constantly spoiled and pampered like a bunch of overgrown psychotic manchildren. Or money for food and stuff.

  • parthasarathy Venkatadri
    parthasarathy Venkatadri 3 ngày trước

    What if the ruler just had an army of droids that perfectly follow every command and are of absolute loyalty to the ruler ... Now imagine the ruler is himself a droid that is connected to every other droid directly essentially a Borg

  • Eskew Roberts
    Eskew Roberts 3 ngày trước

    I've seen this video before, why is it in recommended vids? Why isn't the red bar under it?
    Nevertheless, it's still a really good video, still re-watched it

  • Benjamin S
    Benjamin S 4 ngày trước

    I understand the need for this sadly, but do we really need the facade?

  • Mckenzie Welsh
    Mckenzie Welsh 4 ngày trước

    The democracy is Lib Dems vs greens

  • Flavius Aetius
    Flavius Aetius 4 ngày trước

    Disagree Grey, that middle area is stableeee

  • Sunny T
    Sunny T 4 ngày trước

    This medicine taste bad

  • bradwatson7324
    bradwatson7324 4 ngày trước

    Voluntarism 2020 (free markets; not rulers)

  • Matias Yp
    Matias Yp 4 ngày trước

    If that so what about crazy high tax in European nations ? They literely have higher tax compare to China

    • tom marchianti
      tom marchianti 2 ngày trước

      And in the PRC, the governement spending is in pair with individual investissement, for exemple, many chinese spend some to a lot of monney in the infrastructure, to get less tax on the transport, and others advantages. So the state and the provinces have less to spend on it.

    • J gw
      J gw 2 ngày trước

      The higher tax rate is used to give treasure to the people via free healthcare / public services / infrastructure. If European governments just spent all the extra taxes on themselves then they'd be overthrown.

    • tom marchianti
      tom marchianti 3 ngày trước

      It's because they are social nation (not by the political point of view), but by the fact they give back those tax under the form of bigger services. (And also because they don't have any grows rate, so they make stock, or / and refund or / and keep the truth of their debt keepers and traders).

  • Jose
    Jose 4 ngày trước

    How does this video explain the case of China 🇨🇳?
    A super industrialized power governed by a dictatorship???

    • J gw
      J gw 2 ngày trước

      China isn't a dictatorship. It is a totalitarian state, but there isn't a single all powerful dictator.

  • Bobby Nanashi
    Bobby Nanashi 5 ngày trước

    Are you sir a Satanist too??

  • willisverynice
    willisverynice 5 ngày trước

    And then... 2016

  • JonnyTBooker
    JonnyTBooker 5 ngày trước

    Looks "Smart" and "correct" on the surface but this video is in fact WRONG!!!!
    Nice try.......

    • J gw
      J gw 2 ngày trước

      Elaborate or STFU

  • michael ferris
    michael ferris 5 ngày trước +3

    I think the consequences of Humans Need Not Apply could seriously mix up the balance of power in this key analogy. If democracies rely on a productive populace to incentivize them to take care of their citizens, I wonder what the consequences of wide spread automation might be? What might happen to the balance of power when the people no longer play a role in the treasury or the keys to power. For that matter, what if general intelligence allowed for perfectly loyal keys for dictators. You may be able to circumvent your keys entirely, which could allow for the benevolent dictator to remain in power indefinitely. Or you might just kill everyone to cement your rule I suppose.

    • michael ferris
      michael ferris 2 ngày trước

      @J gw That really depends on how capable the AI is, the only real advantage humans have over machines is our brain, if AI becomes equivalent or smarter than us we might become economically obsolete. Past technologies didn't threaten to replace brainpower, so it's not a fair comparison.

    • J gw
      J gw 2 ngày trước

      New jobs will be created to replace the old, just as they have done with every technological advance. The impact of automation is seriously overblown.

  • VeniVdVici
    VeniVdVici 5 ngày trước

    Ayne Rand is a dystopian cynic...

  • Alphex
    Alphex 5 ngày trước

    arma 3 altis much 0:04

  • Eggmon -
    Eggmon - 5 ngày trước +4

    0:15 well because they are inanimate objects used for measuring things.

  • Jakee
    Jakee 6 ngày trước

    Then you were also saying that citizens will be replaced by robots in the next decades? Man Im confused now.

  • Hugo Fernandes
    Hugo Fernandes 6 ngày trước

    theres a missing key in all of this.. wich is .. technology .. technology change the way people see the world, interact with each other, and , democratised technology removes power from the few to the many.

  • SS G
    SS G 6 ngày trước +1

    Now I Understand My Country 🇮🇳 Super Big Democracy !

  • diego alvarado
    diego alvarado 6 ngày trước

    ES UNA VERGA ESTE VIDEO...

  • Animus_2001
    Animus_2001 6 ngày trước +2

    0:04 Thats the Greek island of Lemnos where I was born !

  • RedRocket4000
    RedRocket4000 6 ngày trước

    Good summary of many basics and especially of how bad dictatorship work. Does not cover how idea's and beliefs modify this at times. Example modern Professional Army concept takes the Army as a part that has to be paid off with actual wealth out of the power fight while still keeping it to keep other powers in line. The Additional advantage is Professional Armies made up of Civil Servants win on the battle field vs in it for a profit mercenaries. Corruption with professional Armies it the buying off of contractors and voters in a Area and Weapon buying that corrupt on the edges. Still a Professional Army can work for Dictatorships that is smart enough to keep it Professional.
    Old concept of Devine Right of Kings and importance of blood lines actually did work with few exceptions to limit possible chalangers but still Kings way more likely to be killed than democracy leaders.

    • RedRocket4000
      RedRocket4000 6 ngày trước

      Oh forgot Religious or Revolutionary Fever can temporarily, a Generation or two at most normally, over come these rules and the infighting if any is over who is more devote and policy not money. But as time passes the passion dies and things revert to these rules.

  • Aviation Now
    Aviation Now 6 ngày trước +1

    The country he showed at the start was Hong Kong

    • tom marchianti
      tom marchianti 3 ngày trước

      HK is'nt a country, look the definition.

  • Fodio Abba
    Fodio Abba 6 ngày trước +1

    I love the matchstick animation!!!

  • Aussie Anger
    Aussie Anger 6 ngày trước

    Lol that map of Lemnos and or altis at the start

  • Jorge Fuentes
    Jorge Fuentes 6 ngày trước

    Hmmm... i see now




    i didn't understand anything

  • I'm Bored-FA
    I'm Bored-FA 6 ngày trước

    storming the capital is just a fantasy. so your not gonna acknowledge whats going on in Iraq at this very moment?

  • Alex Zetsu
    Alex Zetsu 6 ngày trước +1

    I read the title and thought this would be some "power to the people, democracy is for every nation" moralizing thing I was pleasantly surprised this was actually a descent analysis.

  • pyropulse
    pyropulse 6 ngày trước

    Corruption isn't a bug, it's a feature.

  • Ultra Nyan
    Ultra Nyan 6 ngày trước

    Welcome to the introduction of Political Nihilism

  • nikirki25
    nikirki25 6 ngày trước

    *shoots every key who doesn't want to be a f***ing key*

  • Tsar Fox
    Tsar Fox 7 ngày trước +1

    Wise words friend. Wise words. More would do well to keep this in mind.

  • Ze Frendly Medic
    Ze Frendly Medic 7 ngày trước

    0:03 Altis?

  • Atlas
    Atlas 7 ngày trước

    8:38 CGP Grey arma collab confirmed

  • Gustoft Vodka
    Gustoft Vodka 7 ngày trước

    *I love democracy*

  • Timothy Dingman
    Timothy Dingman 7 ngày trước

    I am experiencing the third impeachment in my lifetime. In school, I studied philosophy and I have long been aware of the Platonic concept of the "Benevolent Dictator." It's a dumb idea as demonstrated by Paul Wolfowitz, G. Bush, D. Cheney et.al. Neo Platonism 101

  • Lasersummit
    Lasersummit 7 ngày trước

    0:05 why is that a map of altis, lemnos lol. arma 3 reference?

  • SAS 14
    SAS 14 7 ngày trước

    There are so many historical actions that can counter this video only a small amount of civil wars or coups have happened like this but any major ones like the Russian revolution Chinese revolution or the us civil war were made of the common people they did seize arm stashes but they controlled few generals but more people and after the war Stalin purged any Tsarit officers and Stalin purged them too and in America many of those politicians who rebelled just had their reputation destroyed like maybe this is kinda coherent with somewhere like Thailand? Bolivia or Lybia but this is really inconsistent

  • Raven Crest
    Raven Crest 7 ngày trước

    Be a sovereign king, remove the corrupt influencers who hold power and put others in their place that will obey you. And 100% have the military backing you. Bigger army diplomacy.

  • TrashPanda 365
    TrashPanda 365 7 ngày trước +1

    "Meet the new boss

    Same as the old boss"

    "Power tends to corrupt, and absolute power corrupts absolutely"

  • I have to wait 90 days to change my name

    Instructions very clear. Became a dictator, changed the words positive and negative in my language to “Aladeen” and have Osama in my Guess house

  • vivi xD
    vivi xD 8 ngày trước +2

    So the only way to be an efficient dictator is to automate everything

    Lesson learned.

    May not be feasible right now
    But 20 to 30 years from now

  • Aidan Bazan
    Aidan Bazan 8 ngày trước

    So I'm way behind but I'm just listening to cortex, and got to the point where he's renting an office talking his lines out loud with Thunder sounds playing and he was working on this vehicle. Anyone who overheard probably thought he was a lunatic.

  • Joseph Stalin
    Joseph Stalin 8 ngày trước +1

    Can confirm can’t elimate those who don’t vote for you

  • The Lone Wanderer
    The Lone Wanderer 8 ngày trước

    18:00 “Maybe... you’ll be different...”

  • The Lone Wanderer
    The Lone Wanderer 8 ngày trước

    Very disturbing

  • The Lone Wanderer
    The Lone Wanderer 8 ngày trước

    Interesting but leaves a lot of details out

  • _ VesBraun
    _ VesBraun 8 ngày trước

    Cool video idea: How to be a good key (supporter).